The elegance begins with valet parking since we arrived during a full blown thunderstorm and having the valet with an umbrella in hand was a nice touch. Once inside, the fine dining ambiance continued. The brown cloth draped ceiling is very classic and serves as a stark contrast to the previous incarnations of the building. The service is now impeccable and done with a sense of humor. We found the dining room exceptionally crowded for a rainy Thursday evening. Expecting high prices, the wine list was a pleasant surprise with many affordable vintages of quality.
Quickly, we received a complementary appetizer plate that included three small bites, each with intriguing flavors, though there was no description as to exactly what they were. The bread that arrived was warm and very unique as well. As the waiter went over the menu, variations were included in his description. For example, he offered me an orange marlin (described as a kind of a mix between blue marlin and orange roughy) done in the same way as another seafood entrée from the menu. My dining companion had the seafood ravioli which was rich and filling. For dessert, the cheesecake was adequate but the chocolate cream dessert was over the top, rich creamy, chocolate at its best. I will not overdo the blandishments but Monarch is definitely top of the line and a welcome addition to Maplewood.
We made a second visit to Monarch for our fourth wedding anniversary. I made the reservation on Open Table and explicitly stated that we were married in Canada to avoid any skepticism. The service is absolutely first rate and at the same time there is this subtle sense of snobbery. I find it an interesting combination.
As before we started with the chef’s special treat of the day which was an interesting flavor combination of a tiny piece of cheesecake topped with finely chopped peppers that had a slight vinegar kick. I am not sure I really liked it. The bread arrived around the same time as the very nice red wine we ordered. It is labeled for them as Monarch and is from the Napa Valley. It was an awesome 2004 merlot with hints of chocolate and smooth tannins.
Carol was very tempted to order an appetizer spread and I believe if it had not been a Monday night with such a busy work week ahead of us both, we might have gone for the chef’s tasting menu. We settled on just one, the pan seared scallops which were heavenly. We then decided to order an entrée off the menu. I started with a salad of baby greens, fried apples, red Windsor cheese, pistachios, warm pancetta topped with red wine vinaigrette. As an entrée, I had the pistachio encrusted lamb chops with a bing cherry sauce and shiitake beurre blanc and yes, it was an evening all about pistachios. On the side were brie whipped potatoes and green beans. Carol ordered the grilled walleye that was topped with a dill yogurt cream, caramelized onions, toasted almonds and on the side wild rice and asparagus. For dessert, they treated us to a rich chocolate tort topped with one candle and thanked us for sharing our special day with them.
